High prey drive dog and sulcata

HanzoHasashi

Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2025
Messages
12
Location (City and/or State)
Missouri
Hey all. I have a 9-month-old sulcata and a 2-year-old Russian. My sulcata is in an indoor closed chamber but my Russian is currently outside in her outdoor enclosure enjoying the warmth and 55-70% relative humidity of the Midwestern summer season.

I have two yorkies, 4 and 6 years old respectively (about 9 pounds each, on the smaller side). They initially showed no interest in my tortoises, but Cece (4-year-old, female, high prey drive) has become fixated on the Russian lately. She's too small to get into the enclosure (which also has a secured top), and I've used long black pet gates to fence off the enclosure so she can't even really see into the enclosure anymore, so that problem is solved.

That said, she's gotten savvy to where the sulcata (Buddha) is. Cece is eager to get into the room and sniffs around the table on which the enclosure sits, and follows me in there when I go to give Buddha his daily soaks, and it's clearly a hunting reaction, not simple curiosity.

Buddha is eventually going to need the entire yard. Cece has an incredibly high prey drive. She has, unfortunately, claimed the lives of several critters that frequent the backyard. I can't even begin to describe the cunning this dog demonstrates when she sees something she wants. She is fast, she is clever, she figures out when to sneak, stalk, and whatnot. I say this to impress just how strong her prey drive us. We've done nothing to encourage this and in fact, we've tried discouraging this drive, but we haven't had much luck. She's been this way since we got her when she was 4 months old. I don't want to implement a half measure, like dividing the yard, or portioning off a small section for the dogs, since the backyard is a big part of their enrichment. The Russian tortoise has the benefit of a closed and secure enclosure, but Buddha won't, since he's going to need all the space he can get.

I wish this weren't an issue, but these dogs are going to live a long time. I was hopeful when the dogs didn't show any interest, and believed we could make it work (still hope we can).

My questions are:

- is there a world in which Cece can somehow be trained to overcome her prey drive as it relates to the tortoises?
- will Buddha's eventual bigger size allow him to, I don't know, discourage Cece from messing with him? Like, is a little yorkie with high prey drive going to go after a large reptile three or four times her size? Pretty sure this is wishful thinking on my part.

@Tom I know you're a pro dog trainer so your input would be appreciated here! Ultimately, I'm going to do what's in the best interest of the animals. I'll surrender Buddha if it becomes clear there's not a good solution, but I also don't want to do that unless I have to, since I'm skeptical of anyone's ability to give him the proper care (and it will be at least two more years before Buddha would be outside anyway, so it's not at all urgent).
 

COmtnLady

Well-Known Member
Tortoise Club
5 Year Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2020
Messages
4,434
Location (City and/or State)
Colorado
This is really Tom's ballywick, but -

Think of how CeCe is when a bigger dog or a cat is visible. Her size isn't the key factor, its the attitude. She will get to Buddha the one time you get distracted, or someone else leaves something open.

Its going to be a hard choice.


.
 

wellington

Well-Known Member
Moderator
10 Year Member!
Tortoise Club
Platinum Tortoise Club
Joined
Sep 6, 2011
Messages
53,941
Location (City and/or State)
Chicago, Illinois, USA
Dogs and tortoises should never ever be able to get together as the dog will always at some point hurt or try to hurt or kill the tortoise.
Doesn't matter size of dog either.
On the reverse of that, a large sulcata could easily hurt or kill a medium to small dog, possibly even a large one if the tortoise takes it just right or squishes it.
 

Yvonne G

Old Timer
10 Year Member!
Platinum Tortoise Club
Joined
Jan 23, 2008
Messages
95,407
Location (City and/or State)
Clovis, CA
My first thought was to somehow make the tortoise unpalatable to the dog. . . like somehow fix mouse traps to the tortoise that snap when the dog touches him. I know that's out in left field, just an example.
 

Miles&Marvin

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2022
Messages
31
Location (City and/or State)
Los Angeles
Hey all. I have a 9-month-old sulcata and a 2-year-old Russian. My sulcata is in an indoor closed chamber but my Russian is currently outside in her outdoor enclosure enjoying the warmth and 55-70% relative humidity of the Midwestern summer season.

I have two yorkies, 4 and 6 years old respectively (about 9 pounds each, on the smaller side). They initially showed no interest in my tortoises, but Cece (4-year-old, female, high prey drive) has become fixated on the Russian lately. She's too small to get into the enclosure (which also has a secured top), and I've used long black pet gates to fence off the enclosure so she can't even really see into the enclosure anymore, so that problem is solved.

That said, she's gotten savvy to where the sulcata (Buddha) is. Cece is eager to get into the room and sniffs around the table on which the enclosure sits, and follows me in there when I go to give Buddha his daily soaks, and it's clearly a hunting reaction, not simple curiosity.

Buddha is eventually going to need the entire yard. Cece has an incredibly high prey drive. She has, unfortunately, claimed the lives of several critters that frequent the backyard. I can't even begin to describe the cunning this dog demonstrates when she sees something she wants. She is fast, she is clever, she figures out when to sneak, stalk, and whatnot. I say this to impress just how strong her prey drive us. We've done nothing to encourage this and in fact, we've tried discouraging this drive, but we haven't had much luck. She's been this way since we got her when she was 4 months old. I don't want to implement a half measure, like dividing the yard, or portioning off a small section for the dogs, since the backyard is a big part of their enrichment. The Russian tortoise has the benefit of a closed and secure enclosure, but Buddha won't, since he's going to need all the space he can get.

I wish this weren't an issue, but these dogs are going to live a long time. I was hopeful when the dogs didn't show any interest, and believed we could make it work (still hope we can).

My questions are:

- is there a world in which Cece can somehow be trained to overcome her prey drive as it relates to the tortoises?
- will Buddha's eventual bigger size allow him to, I don't know, discourage Cece from messing with him? Like, is a little yorkie with high prey drive going to go after a large reptile three or four times her size? Pretty sure this is wishful thinking on my part.

@Tom I know you're a pro dog trainer so your input would be appreciated here! Ultimately, I'm going to do what's in the best interest of the animals. I'll surrender Buddha if it becomes clear there's not a good solution, but I also don't want to do that unless I have to, since I'm skeptical of anyone's ability to give him the proper care (and it will be at least two more years before Buddha would be outside anyway, so it's not at all urgent).
We have 3 dogs and also have a Russian and a Sulcata. We socialized them quite a bit very supervised. We would bring them all in the house and sit together. Give treats together. Let the dogs know the torts are part of our family. The Russian is still small 5 lbs but the Sulcata is now 65 lbs. Dogs hardly acknowledge them now, sometime a sniff and walk away. They all figured it out. IMG_4752.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4446.jpeg
    IMG_4446.jpeg
    2.1 MB · Views: 1
  • IMG_4414.jpeg
    IMG_4414.jpeg
    2.7 MB · Views: 1
  • IMG_3029.jpeg
    IMG_3029.jpeg
    1.5 MB · Views: 1

Tom

The Dog Trainer
10 Year Member!
Platinum Tortoise Club
Joined
Jan 9, 2010
Messages
68,546
Location (City and/or State)
Southern California
Hey all. I have a 9-month-old sulcata and a 2-year-old Russian. My sulcata is in an indoor closed chamber but my Russian is currently outside in her outdoor enclosure enjoying the warmth and 55-70% relative humidity of the Midwestern summer season.

I have two yorkies, 4 and 6 years old respectively (about 9 pounds each, on the smaller side). They initially showed no interest in my tortoises, but Cece (4-year-old, female, high prey drive) has become fixated on the Russian lately. She's too small to get into the enclosure (which also has a secured top), and I've used long black pet gates to fence off the enclosure so she can't even really see into the enclosure anymore, so that problem is solved.

That said, she's gotten savvy to where the sulcata (Buddha) is. Cece is eager to get into the room and sniffs around the table on which the enclosure sits, and follows me in there when I go to give Buddha his daily soaks, and it's clearly a hunting reaction, not simple curiosity.

Buddha is eventually going to need the entire yard. Cece has an incredibly high prey drive. She has, unfortunately, claimed the lives of several critters that frequent the backyard. I can't even begin to describe the cunning this dog demonstrates when she sees something she wants. She is fast, she is clever, she figures out when to sneak, stalk, and whatnot. I say this to impress just how strong her prey drive us. We've done nothing to encourage this and in fact, we've tried discouraging this drive, but we haven't had much luck. She's been this way since we got her when she was 4 months old. I don't want to implement a half measure, like dividing the yard, or portioning off a small section for the dogs, since the backyard is a big part of their enrichment. The Russian tortoise has the benefit of a closed and secure enclosure, but Buddha won't, since he's going to need all the space he can get.

I wish this weren't an issue, but these dogs are going to live a long time. I was hopeful when the dogs didn't show any interest, and believed we could make it work (still hope we can).

My questions are:

- is there a world in which Cece can somehow be trained to overcome her prey drive as it relates to the tortoises?
- will Buddha's eventual bigger size allow him to, I don't know, discourage Cece from messing with him? Like, is a little yorkie with high prey drive going to go after a large reptile three or four times her size? Pretty sure this is wishful thinking on my part.

@Tom I know you're a pro dog trainer so your input would be appreciated here! Ultimately, I'm going to do what's in the best interest of the animals. I'll surrender Buddha if it becomes clear there's not a good solution, but I also don't want to do that unless I have to, since I'm skeptical of anyone's ability to give him the proper care (and it will be at least two more years before Buddha would be outside anyway, so it's not at all urgent).
The simple answer is to always keep them separate, and each animal should have its own dedicated area that is not shared. That is the only safe way to do it.

Another issue that people seldom think of is the poop. The tortoise will eat the dog poop and the dogs will eat the tortoise poop. Neither should be happening.

Your questions:
1. No. There is no world in which your dog will forget or ignore its most primal instincts. Not even with professional training.
2. I've seen cases where yorkie sized dog have chewed on 100 pound tortoises. I haven't personally seen a case yet, but I would not be surprised to learn that some small dog was killed or injured by a large heavy tortoise. So no, the size won't make it safe for either of them.

Have you heard of rattlesnake aversion training? If done correctly, it really does work and saves dog lives. This is the tactic to take with tortoises and dogs. Teach the dogs to "leave it", stay away from it and avoid it at all costs. Teach the dog that a tortoise possess magical correction powers and they should stay well away from it.

What often happens is people try out one strategy or another. Many people, like @Miles&Marvin in the post above, try to introduce the dogs and get them used to each other. I can tell you from both first hand and lots of second hand experience, that this is a mistake and often ends in catastrophe months or years later. I can't even count the number of times I've been asked for help from someone with a chewed up tortoise in their hands and tears in their eyes saying, "But the dog ignored him for all these years...", and the always classic "He's never done that before..." No dog has ever done anything until the first time it does it. What people need to learn BEFORE SOMETHING BAD HAPPENS, is that the dog is very likely going to chew up the tortoise at some point or other, one way or another, and no amount of effort or training will stop this. The lesson is this: Keep them separate.
 

Tom

The Dog Trainer
10 Year Member!
Platinum Tortoise Club
Joined
Jan 9, 2010
Messages
68,546
Location (City and/or State)
Southern California
We have 3 dogs and also have a Russian and a Sulcata. We socialized them quite a bit very supervised. We would bring them all in the house and sit together. Give treats together. Let the dogs know the torts are part of our family. The Russian is still small 5 lbs but the Sulcata is now 65 lbs. Dogs hardly acknowledge them now, sometime a sniff and walk away. They all figured it out. View attachment 401258
You've made a mistake. Introducing the dogs to the tortoises is the wrong way to go. I say this because I have personally seen it fail time and time again. I'm not telling you this to hurt your feeling or insult you. Quite the opposite, I'm telling you this in an effort to prevent a tragedy that I have seen dozens of times. I want to help you. It's not too late. You don't have to learn this lesson the hard way.

Understand that I am telling you this as a career professional dog trainer and tortoise keeper. I've been training dogs professionally since the early 90s, and I've titled dogs and won multiple national championships in the hardest dog sport there is. All I do is train animals all day every day. I don't ever want to see another tortoise get chewed up by a dog, and this is my friendly effort to try to prevent it.

Also, your sulcata shouldn't be walking on those bricks. The abrasion will eventually wear through his feet and you will come home to bloody foot prints. There have been several examples of this here on the forum over the years. Just trying to help. After enough years and enough tortoises, you start to see common patterns. You learn what works and what causes problems. I'm just trying to share this info with you and anyone reading, so nobody has to learn the hard way after a terrible problem has occurred.
 

wendigo

Active Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2021
Messages
54
Location (City and/or State)
Florida
I have 3 extremely high prey drive dogs (whippets), they regularly kill squirrels, birds and snakes in the yard. My solution is never together with the tortoises, and I do have electric fence around open enclosures in the yard where the dogs have access. They also have a pretty solid "LEAVE IT" which helps if they were ever together unexpectedly, and are also all trained to wear muzzles. The best way to handle it is they have their own separate spaces. Tortoises and dogs can be fine for years, until one day they aren't and it's usually the tortoise who suffers.
 

New Posts

Top