Moderator review?????????????

[yagyujubei]

I just tried to make a reply to a thread in the reviews section. I was told all new replys are subject to moderation, and my reply disapeared. Why?

 

[Josh]

Vendor reviews are moderated before being posted to eliminate any questionable posts.

 

[yagyujubei]

My point is that a self admitted new member posts a bitter diatribe against a vendor, and I get censored?

 

[Neal]

Josh - Would you consider opening the review section to some commentary? Even moderated commentary?

The way it is now, I'm really not seeing much value in the vendor review section. If someone posts a review with questionable and incomplete information, I think it would a more useful tool if others were able to ask questions about the experiences they're sharing, or ask them to elaborate on what they present. I also tried posting a reply to a review thread, and it is not showing up...I would really like to know more about what exactly happened and get all of the facts publicly. That way, it is fair to all parties involved.

Sure, I could do a PM, but how is that going to be helpful for someone who stumbles on the thread a year from now? and again, how would that be fair to someone who has a negative review posted about them here?

 

[ALDABRAMAN]

I have posted several in the past and they have not been applied or posted also! I feel every members experience, positive or negative should be applied for others to review.