A tortoise that has been brought into captivity cannot be released back into the wild. An introduced disease could wipe out the entire wild population.
PLEASE HELP IDENTIFYING MY SPECIES OF TURTLE OR TORTOISE
- Thread starter DjAyy
- Start date
- Status
Why do you think this? Have you done this?
I ask because I don't believe that to be the case. Tortoises operate on so much instinct and can survive long periods without food and water, plus they have mobile protection from predators wherever they go. I think a head started CB baby that is native to an area and deposited into a suitable area within its natural range would stand a very good chance of not only surviving, but thriving. I would cite Tomas Diagne's sulcata repopulation efforts in Senegal, and the extensive work done in this area with Galapagos tortoises. On one island they have been incubating and head starting eggs to get them past the stage where introduced rats are a threat, and then reintroducing them since the mid 80's. They are finding that the head-started CB babies are actually doing better than the older wild tortoises on that island and growing to a much larger size. The problem seems to be the opposite of your assertion above.
A very warm welcome to the forum ! 
Sorry, don't know what species your cute tort is. Please read the "Beginners Mistakes" Thread and keep your tort warm, making sure there's enough humidity.
Give your tortoise daily soaks in warm water so as to avoid pyramiding and dehydration.
Any pics of his enclosure?
Sorry, don't know what species your cute tort is. Please read the "Beginners Mistakes" Thread and keep your tort warm, making sure there's enough humidity.
Give your tortoise daily soaks in warm water so as to avoid pyramiding and dehydration. Any pics of his enclosure?
Hello, Tom.
Am i next on your list of people to attack and force off the forum ?Not a problem as i'm not about much now, anyway.
You see, the thing is your first question is quite valid.
The second is stupid and insulting. You know perfectly well that i don't go about reintroducing tortoises into the wild and seeing if they die or not.
This is how you do it, proper question couched by an insult and then say I never meant anything. Clever attacks on anyone who might not agree in some regard to your particular and extensive experience of tortoises. You wind them up, play the innocent and then they go ballistic and get banned or just leave the forum.
Okay, question two. No, i have not done this with tortoises. My Tidgy is a rescue and is very used to human companionship and lifestyle, she is mainly fed by hand (I do know) and i am quite convinced will not last terribly long in the wild. Am I going to experiment with her or the other dozen or so torts i help look after here ? No.
It's like the coiled bulb thing that you are so keen on , or the humidity, i will not try that out on tortoises to see the results, you may have had these experiences but i won't risk it, trust your experiences and those of the others that I have read about.
However, I have a doctorate in conservation and have released many other animals in the wild which were captive bred. Usually, the outcome is not good, and i am talking about years of experience here. Tortoises, indeed, have instinct, but you should know that instinct is not a key to a guaranteed survival. The natural mortality rate of tortoises (and most other species) is horrendous, they live longer if kept well in captivity. Instinct will not necessarily protect them from a predator they have not encountered before, they may not be protected or immune to/ from the natural parasites in the area and won't know what is safe to eat ,etc.
First question:
Your belief is interesting, But clearly not based on empirical results other than the one or two examples you mentioned, which are rare and exceptional cases (though nice). You only ever take the examples you like, never see the broad picture, so i can quote you https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Species_reintroduction, which shows some of the pros and cons (ok, it's wiki, I know) , which talks about predators but is still interesting,http://www.wildlifeextra.com/go/news/animal-release739.html#cr, similar, http://www.bornfree.org.uk/campaigns/zoo-check/uk-zoos/zoo-conservation/do-zoos-help-conservation/, this one talks about non carniverous species, and of course i can list more until the cows come home.
In my experience with such animals as tigers, gibbons and elephants (many others too) a massive percentage die very quickly after release, even into a safe natural environment; if they are captive bred, they have almost no chance, if released from the wild after capture or injury, a much better, but still low chance.
There are exceptions, as with your examples, but I would NEVER advocate the release of a captive bred tortoise into the wild. The Galapagos islands are virtually predator (and human) free. The USA is not. It isn't a fair comparison.
People , do not release your captive breds into the wild.
Last edited:
It definitely IS a gopher tortoise - protected in Florida
Besides that, it's against the law. This tortoise needs to be turned over to the authorities or a rescue center.
Whaaaaaa??? If it was April I'd call April fools on you. Since its not April, you win for biggest over reaction on the internet for the day.
I'm just making conversation with a forum friend. Well I thought you were a friend, but apparently you have other ideas of me that I had no idea about… I was genuinely asking if you had first hand experience releasing CB animals back into the wild, and it appears my questions was not so far off base because you DO have such experience. I was trying to engage you in conversation, not attack you or run you off. Sheesh. Lighten up man. I like you. Why would I want to run you off? Did you not know that?
In any case, I don't disagree with you about releasing mammals or birds or other animals that need a fair amount of "training" and raising by their wild parents, but I can think of so many examples of reptiles insects and amphibians that were CB and released into the wild and thrive to the point of becoming and invasive pest species. RES, Iguanas, pythons, cane toads, etc… Can you give me some examples of failed reptile re-introduction attempts, just for the sake of friendly conversation?
Possibly an overreaction, (it's one word) , but I doubt it's the biggest on the internet, though maybe in the Tortoise Forum for the day.
i am sorry if you are offended, though, obviously you will be, but as i said, your second question was badly phrased.
This is exactly what I said .
You insult people and then say, "No, I didn't mean it".
Maybe you don't, but it comes over like that.
Not sure what 'run you off' means.
Regarding your friendly conversation, i am not, as i said, personally aware of many examples of failed reptile introduction other than our crocodiles.
We kept crocodiles in our reserves and goodness they could breed.
(here's another unpopularity vote for Adam.)
But anyway, we 'culled' some of them and made them into handbags and shoes to finance the bigger project. I know, people, but we got very little money from the government. The project ended with reserves all over Thailand, fifty tigers to hundreds etc. My legacy there, the King, whom i met twice and has this week, sadly died, personally thanked me for the work i did for his country.And I got shot, three times, but one of them was me.
Goodness, I don't usually speak of this.
Anyway, we released crocodiles back into the river systems and before long they were spreading out along the river systems in the country and eating the farmer's goats and sheep and things. And one of my friends got killed. That's reptiles, don't release crocs into the wild, i'm aware this is not torts , but you did specify reptiles, I've no personal experience of releasing torts into the wild, as I stated but http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-28658569.
Yes , i know this is invasive and there are hundreds of other examples, but ecosystems adapt to the absence of species.
Do you want to put your native species back where they belong in the middle of LA for example ?
i am sorry if you are offended, though, obviously you will be, but as i said, your second question was badly phrased.
This is exactly what I said .
You insult people and then say, "No, I didn't mean it".
Maybe you don't, but it comes over like that.
Not sure what 'run you off' means.
Regarding your friendly conversation, i am not, as i said, personally aware of many examples of failed reptile introduction other than our crocodiles.
We kept crocodiles in our reserves and goodness they could breed.
(here's another unpopularity vote for Adam.)
But anyway, we 'culled' some of them and made them into handbags and shoes to finance the bigger project. I know, people, but we got very little money from the government. The project ended with reserves all over Thailand, fifty tigers to hundreds etc. My legacy there, the King, whom i met twice and has this week, sadly died, personally thanked me for the work i did for his country.And I got shot, three times, but one of them was me.
Goodness, I don't usually speak of this.
Anyway, we released crocodiles back into the river systems and before long they were spreading out along the river systems in the country and eating the farmer's goats and sheep and things. And one of my friends got killed. That's reptiles, don't release crocs into the wild, i'm aware this is not torts , but you did specify reptiles, I've no personal experience of releasing torts into the wild, as I stated but http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-28658569.
Yes , i know this is invasive and there are hundreds of other examples, but ecosystems adapt to the absence of species.
Do you want to put your native species back where they belong in the middle of LA for example ?
I'm not offended in the least. Just surprised that you thought I would want to attack you and force (aka run…) you off of the forum. Hope we are all good and on the same page now.
Anyhow… So it sounds like your re-introduced CB crocs help to prove my point that CB reptiles, to include tortoises, often survive when re-released back into the wild. Which is why I started the conversation in regards to your initial comment on this thread that re-released CB tortoises were not likely to survive. I think they would be likely to survive, but I think we all agree that in most cases, captive animals, whether CB or WC should not be released into the wild.
Quite right.
Same page I hope.
I have said that you are the forum's most valuable asset and stand by that.
But sometimes a little insensitive ?
However, i did overreact, and I am sorry for that.
I'm a bit stressed at the moment but it is not an excuse to be rude.
Sorry, again.
Oh, and they ate most of the local turtle population, so fifty-fifty.
Well the re-itroduction was successful for the crocs at least…
Definitely blunt and sometimes insensitive for sure. Some people prefer the direct approach and other people seem to like their info sugar coated. I'm bad at sugar coating. At least I seem to be bad at it in the typed word. Thanks for talking this out and I'm sorry for my part in the misunderstanding too.
Back to tortoise conversation now my friend...
Quite right.Well the re-itroduction was successful for the crocs at least…
Definitely blunt and sometimes insensitive for sure. Some people prefer the direct approach and other people seem to like their info sugar coated. I'm bad at sugar coating. At least I seem to be bad at it in the typed word. Thanks for talking this out and I'm sorry for my part in the misunderstanding too.
Back to tortoise conversation now my friend...
Done, my friend.
Oh, and I'm very sorry, DjAyy for making a mess of your thread, but just to explain, we have disagreements on here, but are still able to stay friends!
Tom is right about most things and has far more experience than I.
But don't put it back into the wild.
Which, despite the comments above,is what everyone agrees on.
Tom is right about most things and has far more experience than I.
But don't put it back into the wild.
Which, despite the comments above,is what everyone agrees on.
And I would like to publicly apologize to Tom for unnecessary remarks.
Sorry, OP, and everyone else.
Sorry, OP, and everyone else.
Berkeley
Active Member
- Joined
- May 4, 2014
- Messages
- 296
I see that comment now, but if it is just the one tortoise- and I am betting it was just the one tortoise at the house- it is probably just fine to release it where it was found. The friend he got it from will know where it came from. It obviously has not been in captivity that long. On the extremely small chance it did pick something up, what disease could get introduced into a wild gopher population that isn't (or hasn't) already been found in them?
And it will adjust back to wild living just fine. At the very least, it should be turned over to FWC (Florida Wildlife and Conservation Commission)- it is still illegal to keep one without a permit.
--Berkeley
- Status
Similar threads
