UGH!

[Tom]

Manager...

That guy is full of derogatory fecal matter...

I worked in retail pet for 8 years. I have had 100's of cuttle bones in my hands. They do NOT smell.

 

[Masin]

Contact the manufacturer, they'll replace it. Then make sure to write to the manager and district manager. An employee should never argue with a customer over the quality of a product, never mind it being inexpensive AND a food item/ the potential to be very dangerous if contaminated etc

 

[lMorphine]

I just threw it out but its okay because I was gonna buy a new 125 gallon aquarium, looks like Ill be going to a different store paybacks a bwitch. Dont refund me 2.99, then lose on 300$

 

[Yvonne G]

I'm not joking. I buy it by the 5lb box and it smells fishy.

 

[MooingTricycle]

I'm not joking. I buy it by the 5lb box and it smells fishy.

does the company you buy it from process other fish?

 

[lMorphine]

I know its supposed to smell fishy but this was unbearable I couldnt even leave it open, it smelled so bad.

 

[dmmj]

I buy mine loose from the feed store, and I don't detect a fishy smell.

 

[lMorphine]

I heard its perfectly normal to smell a tad fishy but ofcourse not overbearing. I have a local feed store (the only one) Ill stop in there and get them, probably 1$ each.