Well I was told it was a tortoise, and told the forum it was a tortoise and about my set up, and I got barraged
@Jenna lore You'll notice this forum is very passionate about the health and well-being of animals. I hope you don't take the reaction personally - the thought of a seller telling you to put a tortoise in a fish tank is horrifying, and that's what brought on the responses you got (in my opinion).
I'm very happy to hear he's alive - he looks awesome! I have three water turtles but have no experience with soft shells, however.