Help with second numbers one and two?

[ZEROPILOT]

Recently, the collective identified Redfoot number three as a female. Now please help me with numbers one and two..
Number one I believe is a male and number 2 is thought to be female. Agree or disagree?

 

[G-stars]

I would say both males. 2nd one looks like it has a longer tail.

 

[pfara]

Based on lack of anal notch thickness, going with both girls. But, I'm terrible at these.

 

[Octavious22]

Agree looks like #1 is a male and #2 female

 

[ZEROPILOT]

Split decision?
Number one has a very deeply concave plastron. When you pick him/her up, it is very noticeable. 1 is about 10 inches and 2 is a little smaller.

 

[G-stars]

Split decision?

Looks that way. Get some redfoot experts in on it. As a tie breaker. Or wait until they either flash you or lay eggs???

 

[ZEROPILOT]

Let me summon a young Redfoot wizard! @Turtlepete

 

[Anyfoot]

Recently, the collective identified Redfoot number three as a female. Now please help me with numbers one and two..
Number one I believe is a male and number 2 is thought to be female. Agree or disagree?

Can you get a better view on the tail of third photo. I'm thinking you are right. 1 of each.

 

[Anyfoot]

Can you get a better view on the tail of third photo. I'm thinking you are right. 1 of each.

He has really wide open v anal scutes.

 

[Lyn W]

I would guess..........

#1 female - wide notch for eggs
# 2 male - not such a wide notch

or
#1 male concave plastron
#2 female flatter plastron

....just hedging my bets...
Is there a prize for the winner?

 

[ZEROPILOT]

Number two has very little curve on the plastron and a wide, spade shaped tail.
Number one is deeply concave with a longer thinner tail.

 

[Anyfoot]

Number two has very little curve on the plastron and a wide, spade shaped tail.
Number one is deeply concave with a longer thinner tail.

I'm still thinking 1st one is male. Although if you look on JD's pinned post on how to sex redfoots, there is a female cherryhead very similar to this Tortoise in question. My male cherryhead has a flat plastron. My 2 northern males have deep concave plastron. When he walks is his neck stuck far out. Males have longer necks.

 

[ZEROPILOT]

I'm still thinking 1st one is male. Although if you look on JD's pinned post on how to sex redfoots, there is a female cherryhead very similar to this Tortoise in question. My male cherryhead has a flat plastron. My 2 northern males have deep concave plastron. When he walks is his neck stuck far out. Males have longer necks.

I hope you and I are correct. that would mean that I just got two new females. and one male, that I will find a new home for.

 

[ZEROPILOT]

If anyone is curious, the heading should have read need help sexing numbers one and two. Spell check kicked in and I didn't catch it in time.

 

[Anyfoot]

I hope you and I are correct. that would mean that I just got two new females. and one male, that I will find a new home for.

Do you already have a male. Or don't you want any males.

 

[ZEROPILOT]

I only want one male for my now five females.
I ended up with two males.
I'll have one male too many.

 

[Anyfoot]

I only want one male for my now five females.
I ended up with two males.
I'll have one male too many.

What's happening ed. We ain't getting any confident answers with the sex of your torts. Think you should shout out a bit louder. Lol.
Or shall I

 

[ZEROPILOT]

A very helpful member PMED me.
#1 male, #2 female and number 3 also female.
I was correct and that is unusual.
I think I'll keep the names, too.
Numbers one, two and three, Big Bertha, Ruby,Pedro and Julio.
(Julio got her name as a baby and she looked male)

 

[MPRC]

I agree with the #1 - Male, #2 - Female camp. But I'm a novice.

 

[ZEROPILOT]

I agree with the #1 - Male, #2 - Female camp. But I'm a novice.

A correct novice.