Is that Bonita's butt in the last one.I think Carl's explanation makes sense. I have two girls that have similar plastrons and are more marbled. The black on their shell does seem "thinner" and the growth not a rigid. If my enclosure was more planted, I could see them looking like this. Their areolas are also not as well defined as the standard cherry.
View attachment 185025View attachment 185026View attachment 185027View attachment 185028View attachment 185029
Has her areola got bigger as she's aged?
Could it be over time rather than the carapace wearing thin to reveal more of the areola color it's a case of the areola pigment spreads with age. Has Bonita had abrasion on her carapace because she looks very smooth too. Not talking about pyramiding smooth but the actual surface finish of her scutes being very smooth.