- Joined
- Jun 30, 2011
- Messages
- 217
dmmj said:WOW, so the old " he grows to fast" theory is still around?
Im new to this whole subject, but my Star hatchlings now a year are not "pyramided", however many tortoises in the wild certainly are.
I have studied the growth and management of young horses and can say absolutely along with all studies and control groups that high protein diets too soon encouraging rapid growth lead to chronic joint problems in warm blood adults and three year olds. These are big animals but must be left to mature slowly.
The problem is grass contains a load of protein, add to this horse feed also high in protein leads to trouble. There is though a three tiered program to get the horse through all this in health. One is daily exercise or preferably unlimited excersise sun rain whatever this strengthens bones and joints and is absolutely vital, the other is to reduce protein or supplementary feed to just grass, hay and or silage. The last is absolutely no supplements unless the grazing is very much lacking in certain important elements. This will differ from area to area but is rarely a problem and if it is it will be well known amongst farmers etc.
Im slightly sceptical about the humidity aspect here. Ok tortoises are not horses, but in the wild hatchlings tortoises will go through humid and extremely dry periods in varying seasons as they grow with no ill affects.
Homopus signatus the smallest tortoise on earth will endure wet cold winters and bone dry summers with no humidity at all in the wild they are naturally pyramided but still require spraying to keep up the humidity level in the first three weeks of life. This isn't to prevent pyramiding but to make sure they are hydrated.
As far as I can work out tortoises are slaves to their environment, and this being extremely volatile will adapt , but most importantly at their own pace.
So if a Sulcata is pyramided or not might depend on many different things but essentially is not a problem for health unless incorrect artificial conditions are forced on it. This might mean rapid growth due to feeding but bone dry, or slow growth due to bad diet combined with overly humid conditions where it most probably simply will die if its lucky.
Im rather amazed that no one looks to the natural environment of these creatures for clues. Experiment all you want with humidity protein but until you know how it all come together in its natural environment and naturally variable conditions you will always be blind.
I suppose in fact there are no perfect conditions rather the variables that nature throws its way. They survive all this just swell, given natural sunshine just enough food and periodical months of extreme lean.
Tey are masters of their environment and not of ours. (im Irish of decent give me a break)